Nuria Jiménez-Arévalo*a,
Carlo Marianiab,
Fabrice Leardinic,
Francesco Pandolfib,
Ilaria Ragob and
Riccardo Frisenda*a
aDipartimento di Fisica, Università di Roma “La Sapienza”, 00185, Rome, Italy. E-mail: nuria.jimenezarevalo@uniroma1.it; riccardo.frisenda@uniroma1.it
bIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Sezione di Roma, 00185 Rome, Italy
cDepartamento de Física de Materiales, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, 28049 Madrid, Spain
First published on 28th August 2024
X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) is a widely used and easy accessible characterisation technique for investigating the chemical composition of materials. However, investigating the composition of van der Waals (vdW) flakes by XPS is challenging due to the typical spot size of XPS setups compared to the dimensions of the flakes, which are usually one thousand times smaller than the spot size. In this work, we demonstrate the feasibility of quantitative elemental analysis of vdW materials by using high-throughput mechanical exfoliations, which favour the coverage of arbitrary substrates with flakes of areas of the order of the cm2 using minimal quantities of materials (about 10 μg). We have analysed the chemical composition of MoS2, graphite, WSe2 and FePS3. The high-resolution measurement of their main core levels through XPS demonstrates the absence of significant contamination during the transfer method. In the case of air-sensitive FePS3, the glove box fabrication and its degradation in air are discussed. Overall, this research opens the possibility of evaluating the purity of commercial or lab-synthesized flakes and paves the way towards a more systematic comparison between the composition of vdW materials produced and used among different laboratories.
X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) is a widely used and powerful characterisation technique for investigating the elemental abundances and chemical composition of materials.17–19 However, in conventional laboratory settings, the spatial resolution of XPS typically exceeds 10−1 mm2, which is much larger than the typical size of 2D flakes. Thus, synchrotron radiation is often employed for this purpose,20 even though it is less accessible to a general audience and not suitable for rapid surveys of the chemical composition of the 2D flakes. Therefore, the challenge of easily investigating the elemental composition of mechanically exfoliated 2D flakes using conventional XPS apparatus remained unsolved.
In this work, we employed a similar technique to that developed by Y. Sozen et al.15 to characterise with XPS the composition of various mechanically exfoliated vdW materials transferred on large-area substrates (of the order of 1 cm2), using minimal quantities of the chosen material (approximately 10 μg). This approach enables the possibility of assessing the purity of commercial vdW materials, investigating composition modifications induced by different techniques, or the characterisation of laboratory-produced materials that are typically produced in small quantities. Also, it can ease the comparison of the same 2D material exfoliated or produced by different research groups.
Our findings were validated through a thorough characterisation of MoS2 as the case of study, as well as by the analysis of other vdW materials such as graphite (Gr), WSe2, and FePS3. Notably, the characterisation of air-sensitive FePS3 highlights the capability of performing this transfer method under an inert atmosphere. Additionally, in our investigation, we show the fast degradation of this compound when stored in air by the observation of oxide species by XPS. This underscored the importance of carefully managing environmental factors to maintain the stability of air-sensitive vdW materials.
Overall, this research introduces a valuable tool for characterising vdW material purity and quality, without the necessity of large quantities of materials and can pave the way to a more systematic comparison of vdW materials produced in different laboratories.
Samples were held to the Mo sample holder using Ta strips and were annealed at 120 °C for at least 12 h in UHV before XPS measurements to remove eventual airborne contaminants.
In Fig. 1a, a photograph of the sample under research is given. The sample is approximately 1 cm2 large. In the upper and lower parts of the photograph the Si substrate is revealed; meanwhile, the central part of the sample is covered with the MoS2 flakes. Fig. 1b offers a schematic representation of the deposited MoS2 flakes from different angles. Microscale characterisation (Fig. 1c–e) reveals uncovered spaces where the substrate remains exposed, schematically illustrated in Fig. 1b. Both optical microscopy (OM) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images, performed in the same sample region, show contrast between the MoS2 and the substrates. Nevertheless, it is worth noting that the contrast obtained by SEM is higher than the OM one. Image processing Gwyddion software facilitated estimating the covered area in that region, revealing a coverage COM = (60 ± 5) % by OM and CSEM = (70 ± 5)% by SEM (see Fig. S3†). The higher contrast provided by SEM enables a more accurate and precise estimation of the covered area, as compared to OM, which depends on the refractive indexes of the vdW material and the substrate and on the thickness of the flakes. These findings were also obtained for Gr flakes noticing that, in that case, the SEM image provided an inverted contrast with respect to MoS2 due to the higher conductivity of graphite compared to the Si substrate (see Fig. S4†).
We noted that the area covered along the sample can vary among regions (see Fig. S2c†). Thus, to get a more precise estimation of the area covered, several optical images were acquired in different sample regions and analysed, yielding an average value of COM = (55 ± 5)% for the MoS2 sample. Even though this value provides a lower limit for the coverage, as discussed before, it offers insights into the fraction of area covered by the MoS2 flakes.
Finally, AFM imaging (Fig. 1e) shows that the height of the transferred flakes, with an average value of approximately 90 nm (see Fig. S5†), is in good agreement with the reported value by Y. Sozen et al.15 We noticed that this thickness is larger than the typical probing depth of XPS for the photon energies used in the research, which is in the order of 1–3 nm.21–23
After the morphological characterisation, we proceed to analyse the MoS2 transferred sample using XPS. Fig. 2a displays the survey spectrum of the sample after 12 hours of annealing in UHV at 150 °C, revealing distinct peaks ascribed to MoS2 and Si/SiO2, as labelled in Fig. 2a. Eventually, peaks ascribed to Ta are also observed, coming from the Ta strips that hold the sample in place.
Fig. 2 XPS results for the MoS2 sample transferred onto a Si substrate. (a) Survey spectrum indicating the corresponding peaks with tags. Mo 3d and S 2s (b), S 2p (c) and Si 2p (d) core levels. Experimental data indicated with dots, total fit in red, and Shirley background with a dashed dotted line. The individual peaks are coloured and their corresponding core-levels are indicated in the figure. Fitting parameters can be found in Table S1.† Spectra were recorded with a photon energy hν = 1253.6 eV and a PE of 50 eV. |
By the analysis of the areas of the core levels, normalised to their cross sections, coming from the substrate (Si and O) and of the ones coming from the material under investigation (Mo, S) we were able to estimate a coverage of CXPS = (70 ± 5)%. This result is in good agreement with the results obtained by SEM and OM. It can be then concluded that the analysis of the coverage by morphological techniques, such as SEM or OM, or compositional techniques, such as XPS, point out to a similar coverage of the MoS2 flakes on the Si substrate. Considering the various error sources for the different techniques, the coverages estimated in the three cases are well in agreement with each other (COM = (55 ± 5)%, CSEM = (70 ± 5)%, CXPS = (70 ± 5)%).
A second MoS2 sample obtained with a single transfer (COM = (17 ± 5)%) was also subjected to XPS analysis. Despite the low coverage, well-defined signals were recorded for the survey and single spectra (see Fig. S6 and S7†). In addition, the coverage by XPS was also obtained by comparing the areas of the Mo and S peaks with the ones of Si and O finding a coverage of CXPS = (25 ± 5)%. The good agreement between the OM and XPS estimated coverage is consistent with the previously discussed MoS2 sample showing a higher coverage. A further discussion about this aspect and about the inelastic peak shape analysis24–26 can be found in the ESI (Fig. S8 and S9†).
A detailed examination of the Mo 3d, S 2p, and Si 2p core levels peaks is provided in Fig. 2b, c and d, respectively and in Table S1.† It is noticed the presence of the Mo4+ 3d spin–orbit split doublet (at 229.8 eV and 233.0 eV for the 3d5/2 and 3d3/2) and the presence of S 2s (227.1 eV) core levels,27–31 with no Mo6+ components indicative of molybdenum oxide,27 confirming material purity. The S 2p region displays its corresponding spin–orbit (2p3/2 at 162.6 eV and 2p1/2 at 163.8 eV),27,30 while the Si 2p region exhibits the two Si 2p3/2 (99.7 eV) and Si 2p1/2 (100.3 eV) spin–orbit split doublet32,33 along with a peak centred at 104.0 eV attributed to the SiO2 component,32,33 indicating the presence of surface oxide on Si.
Finally, it is noteworthy the presence of a tiny C 1s peak at around 285.5 eV in the survey spectrum (see Fig. 2a) in comparison with the core levels of the MoS2 flakes. The energy of this peak points to some hydroxide and oxide carbon species34,35 that could indicate the presence of residues from the Nitto tape on top of the transferred flakes or on the substrate. However, this small carbon/molybdenum ratio highlights the cleanliness of the technique employed, despite using a polymeric glue tape and high temperatures, suggesting that the presence of residue and contaminants is minimal.
To demonstrate the general nature and applicability of this technique to various vdW materials, graphite flakes and WSe2 flakes were also deposited onto Si wafers. The morphological characterisation can be found in the ESI (Fig. S4 and S10†). Fig. 3 displays the survey spectra and the main core levels of these two compounds.
Fig. 3 (a) Survey spectrum for Gr sample and (b) C 1s core level. (c) Survey spectrum for WSe2 sample and (d) Se 3d and (e) W 4f core levels. Experimental data indicated with dots, total fit in red, and Shirley background with a dashed dotted line. The individual peaks are coloured and their corresponding core level is indicated in the figure. Fitting parameters can be found in Tables S2 and S3.† Spectra were recorded with a photon energy hν = 1253.6 eV and a PE of 50 eV. |
In the case of the graphite sample (Fig. 3a and b), a distinct and well-defined peak centred at 284.8 eV is observed,34 along with a shoulder at 285.9 eV corresponding to the oxidised states of carbon and other functionalization groups.34,35 The contribution of this oxide component is 18.5%. Nevertheless, the intensity of this C 1s core level is significantly higher than in the other vdW materials under investigation (as evidenced in Fig. 3a), and the main peak at 284.8 eV indicates a clear presence of sp2 carbon, as expected for Gr flakes.36 The coverage of this sample is COM = (45 ± 5)%, CSEM = (34 ± 5)%, and CXPS = (36 ± 5)% consistent with the previous results of coverage obtained for MoS2.
Additionally, these results were compared with those of highly oriented pyrolytic graphite (HOPG) measured in the same XPS apparatus. HOPG is the most similar bulk system to the Gr-flakes under investigation in this research, as it is composed of layers of graphite crystallites highly oriented along the c axis. In Fig. S11a,† it can be observed that the line shapes of these two graphitic materials closely match. The analysis of the residual difference signal (Fig. S11b†) between these two fits highlights differences at BE above 285.5 eV which is compatible with the presence of functionalized groups, such as hydrocarbons, carbon hydroxides and oxides at higher binding energy,34–36 in the case of Gr-flakes. This is presumably due to a higher density of edges caused by the finite size of the flakes, with respect to the large terraces present in HOPG. Overall, these results are a good validation of this high-throughput massive exfoliation of vdW materials to measure the XPS spectra.
Tungsten diselenide (WSe2) was also analysed by XPS (see Fig. 3c–e). A significant number of core levels ascribed to this compound were recorded in the survey spectrum (Fig. 3c). We focused on measuring the two most intense peaks of each element with high-resolution, which are the Se 3d (Fig. 3d) and the W 4f37–39 (Fig. 3e). Both core-levels show their characteristic spin orbit doublets Se 3d5/2 (54.8 eV), Se 3d3/2 (55.7 eV) and W 4f7/2 (32.6 eV), W 4f5/2 (34.7 eV),37–40 with the absence of oxide components.40
Lastly, FePS3, a magnetic vdW material, was investigated. The peculiarity of this compound is that, unlike the others explored in this work, it was synthesised by some of the authors of the present manuscript. This made this sample of particular interest for elemental investigation and to check the presence of eventual contaminants. Moreover, FePS3 is known in literature for its sensitivity to oxygen species and its tendency to degrade in air,41,42 prompting us to investigate its degradation using XPS.
FePS3 was first transferred onto a Si wafer using the technique reported in the experimental section, conducted in ambient atmosphere. After analysing the composition of the compound by XPS, we observed the signal from some oxide peaks (see ESI, Fig. S12†). However, whether the oxidation occurred during the transfer method or during the synthesis remained uncertain. To address this uncertainty, we fabricated a second sample performing the exfoliation and transfer of FePS3 inside a gloveless anaerobic chamber43 filled with an inert N2 atmosphere. The results obtained for this last sample are reported in Fig. 4.
Fig. 4 XPS results for the FePS3 sample transferred onto a Si substrate. (a) Survey spectrum indicating the corresponding peaks with tags. Fe 2p (b), S 2p (c) and P 2p (d) core levels. Experimental data indicated with dots, total fit in red, and Shirley background with a dashed dotted line. The individual peaks are coloured and their corresponding core-level is indicated in the figure. The grey shadowed line-shape present in the panels (b), (c), and (d) corresponds to the data recorded for the same sample after storing it in air for 20 days. * peaks ascribed to oxygen bonds as discussed in the text. Fitting parameters can be found in Table S4.† Spectra were recorded with a photon energy hν = 1468.7 eV and a PE of 50 eV. |
Fig. 4a presents the survey spectrum for the as-prepared FePS3 sample. Peaks ascribed to this compound are labelled in the figure, evidencing the lack of contamination from unexpected elements and the lack of oxides observed in the sample prepared in air, evidencing the necessity to use inert atmospheres when transferring air-sensitive compounds.
The deconvoluted high-resolution XPS spectrum of FePS3 shows the typical Fe 2p line shape.44–49 Peaks at 709.2 eV and 722.7 eV correspond to the 2p3/2 and 2p1/2 core levels of Fe2+,44,46,48–50 respectively, and peaks at 710.9 eV and 723.7 eV correspond to the Fe3+ 2p3/2 and 2p1/2,46,47,50 respectively. In addition, two satellite peaks are present in the recorded spectrum, already observed and reported for this compound.45,46 The S 2p core level shows the S 2p spin–orbit split doublet at 162.4 eV and 163.5 eV,48,50 which is slightly shifted towards higher binding energies compared to other works in literature44,46,51 but agrees well with the results reported for electrochemically-exfoliated FePS349 and mechanically exfoliated FePS3 by mortar grinding.50 A broad peak was also observed at around 168.5 eV due to the presence of oxides and sulfates.44,49,52 The P 2p core level evidences the spin–orbit doublet at 131.8 eV and 132.7 eV.44,46–49,51
The stability of the compound was further investigated after storing it in air at room temperature for 7 and 20 days. After 7 days, the XPS spectra remained consistent with the as-prepared samples (see Fig. S12†), therefore showing no sign of degradation in this time scale. This result is consistent with previous reports on mechanically exfoliated FePS3 flakes that demonstrated stability for 6 days by Raman spectroscopy.41 However, degradation was observed after 20 days, with noticeable changes in the Fe 2p, S 2p and P 2p core levels (see Fig. 4b–d), also consistent with the degradation of the optoelectronic properties of devices based on FePS3 flakes after some weeks in ambient conditions.42 An increase in the 168.5 eV peak in the S 2p suggests the appearance of sulfates and oxides. Furthermore, we observe a strong change in the P 2p core level with the emergence of an intense peak around 134 eV, also observed on the sample prepared in air (see Fig. S12†), which is ascribed to phosphorous oxide.46,47,53 Finally, the Fe 2p peak increases in intensity and slightly shifts to higher binding energies, probably also due to the presence of oxygen bonds.54,55
Overall, characterising air-sensitive FePS3 by XPS highlights the necessity of employing inert atmospheres when transferring this type of materials through massive parallel heat-assisted exfoliation. Additionally, this work underscores the utility of evaluating the quality of exfoliated vdW materials, as their chemical composition can be modified drastically in short periods of time, thereby impacting the research results.
This work opens up the possibility of controlling the purity of commercial materials and assessing the damage caused by air exposure or other induced modifications. At the same time, it is an easy and straightforward technique for facilitating comparisons of the same 2D materials across different research groups.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4nr02882a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |